Hi Simon
My comments have sort of evolved into questions.
Given that the surfing and the interviews are great and it is truly an insightful documentary, (in general), why, given that the average age of kneelos is, at last check, around 42, was there the need to film so many young women (chicks)?
As Oscar Wilde said “men’s desire does not lesson with age it just becomes more inappropriate” Chicks and men in the forties are not a good match on the whole…radical surfing should see us go beyond most mid-life crisis issues. My wife commented on this immediately and I felt uncomfortable having my daughter watching a girls bum out of context for longer than a second!
I also feel I cannot allow my daughter to see men baring their bums…sure people do it but how does it fit into the kneelo expression…young “stand up” surfer mags issue that stuff…just check the end o year tracks mag for the guy flopping out his dick.
And lastly the drunken song, it starts off innocently but the chap who eyeballs the camera delves deep into what we don’t need to hear.
I do realize it was a “PG” affair! But I feel only “class” should be documented, all else can just drift into ‘you had to be their giggles’
Having the surfers discuss and show their boards could have been a great space filler over the above scenes
Yep these are just my opinions but I’ve got all three flicks and I feel a sort of affinity and critical understanding of the product…given it is aimed at a relatively select few and that I’m apart of that small market.
Again, I am watching it as often as possible for interest and as a source of inspiration, but the above scenes, from my perspective, hold it back from being a timeless document to something that needs refinement. As a man in my 41st year, seeking refinement without being puritanical or falsely pious is reasonable…no?!
regards
dorje aka John